Arcadian Functor

occasional meanderings in physics' brave new world

My Photo
Location: New Zealand

Marni D. Sheppeard

Friday, July 04, 2008

Riemann Again

Sorry Carl, I can't resist. Recall Connes' remark regarding the Riemann Hypothesis that
it is a basic primitive question about the adelic line which we don't understand. It is a question about the way addition is fitting with multiplication.
In this light, the very simple use of the adeles in Li's paper comes across almost as an insult to the spirit of Connes' approach.

One gets the eerie feeling that Li has a strong subconscious sense of a promising line of attack, but that this has led him into the labyrinth of murky delusion, a frightening place of which there is no need to say more. But if nothing else, the paper has caused a lot of bright people to ponder the mystery that is the rational adeles. In M Theory, since a prime $p$ is pretty well always associated (as logos building blocks) to categorical dimension, even if only to count sets, the adeles must be an $\omega$-categorical construction. There is no problem defining rational numbers or appropriate limits in this setting, so the mystery lies in what it means to tack the real numbers on the end, at the infinite prime.

One nice property of the adeles as an Abelian group is that it is isomorphic to its Pontrjagin (Fourier) dual. Somehow this is analogous to the schizophrenic property of the group $U(1)$ in the full Stone duality setting, enriched to the $n$-category hierarchy setting. Or, as kneemo would put it, a string is secretly a necklace of pearls.


Blogger Kea said...

An interesting comment from Monir Mamoun on NCG: it seems to me an elliptic curve functional on the closed measure 0 inside adeles would provide the requisite metric space for an extended test function h; the associated omega-consistent Goedel-zeta function transform would then serve as an adequate ring Hecke for a 1-0 Lie group functional connective space.

And Li has not yet withdrawn the paper.

July 06, 2008 8:18 AM  
Blogger Kea said...

OK, the paper is now withdrawn.

July 06, 2008 6:39 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home